Dec 11, - Below is a quick guide to help you choose the right trainer, and expert picks “speed” sensor from Garmin or CycleOps, and possibly a power meter as well. . a smart trainer capable of transporting you into your favorite virtual cycling . can be controlled by a smartphone, tablet, or Element bike computer.
Maximum replicated slope is 20 percent and maximum power is 2, watts. Good luck with both of those!
As such, it still has lead in how it plays well with others. It is easy to use with all the major apps — and your phone and your Garmin and of course the Wahoo Mefer head units.
Power-wise, indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer KICKR tracks along gratifyingly with power meters, and in fact can dith calibrated to your power meter of choice if you so prefer. With a heavy flywheel and an electro-magnetic brake, the feel is excellent and the trainer is comouter at all speeds. When doing controlled intervals, the KICKR will report that its controlled power and your actual power are eerily close, delivering bar-graph-like results in your wattage reports.
On one hand this can be gratifying to see. On the other, there is no way you are actually holding power that smoothly. But in either case, the Kickr plays well with others, delivers a quiet and trianer smooth ride, and — although heavy like the rest — is relatively best ios app track gps bike to move thanks to the big handle and pop-out adjustable legs.
Looking like a spaceship off the set of Indkor Warsthe Neo lights up the ground with emter coded to your level of effort. With a varied series of short stutters, the Neo can replicate the feel garin, to some extent, the sound of riding over cobbles, dirt roads, loose boards and more.
The Neo also has a cool feature where you get a bit of a boost on downhills. If you coast while on a downhill, then start to pedal again, on most trainers you get a bit of resistance at first. With the Neo, the pedals turn as easily as they would outside. There are metwr two problems with the Neo. One is cost. And two, there is no way to calibrate the thing. Tacx claims that the system comes perfectly adjusted and biks no calibration. That may be the case, but I was frustrated indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer see that while the power readings were very consistent, they were also about 4—8w watts below the calibrated power meters I used for testing.
I did 10 one- to two-hour rides on the Neo, testing against pairs of meters from Shimano, Stages, Garmin and Pioneer. Tacx engineers said drivetrain efficiency losses account for the variation in power measurement at the cranks and pedals. The Neo is a delight to ride; it is quiet, responds quickly and smoothly to resistance changes for virtual undulations or power workouts, and the surface treatments make riding Zwift more engaging than any other trainer.
After doing a calibration with the Tacx app, I found the Tacx Flux to measure power fairly well — within two percent iindoor the Pioneer, Shimano and Garmin power meter averages, with relatively consistent tracking and the ability to catch quick jumps and spikes.
Of more relevance to Zwift riders, the gradient simulation tops out at 10 percent powr the lowest of the direct-drive trainers. Notify me of follow-up comments by email.
Notify me of new posts by email. This site uses Akismet indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed. To get started with virtual power, you need to have the following: Supported bike trainer. Most classic trainers are supported by most applications. Speed and Cadence sensor. Virtual Power With TrainerRoad: Look and Garmin are the two longest-established manufacturers of power-measuring pedals. This design allows trainner easy swapping of the meter between bikes.
Refinements to these pedals in the last couple of years trajner that with the latest models it's as trivial as just reaching for a best bike computer gps spanner.
Both Powertap and Favero also have pedal-based power meters. O-Synce has shown a system at trade shows but it has not yet become available. On the same principal as left-crank meters, most pedal meter makers offer a single-pedal system that provides power data at lower cost. Measuring power in the rear hub must be fairly tricky, as PowerTap remains indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer only manufacturer of a hub power meter, almost two decades years after introducing its first hub.
Supported by relatively flexible frame ends, and hammered by road forces, the hub is a hostile place for delicate electronics, but PowerTap seems to have solved the problems. You can get a PowerTap hub either built into powr wheel or biks pair, or on its own so your favourite wheelbuilder can install your rim of choice.
Witth hub power meter cateye cyclometer the easiest type to switch between bikes, though if you want power readings while racing then you have to train on your racing wheels.
What follows is an overview of all the currently available power meters, that's as comprehensive as we can make it. We kick off with the most recently announced models. PowerTap's P2 pedals are an evolution of the P1 pedals from rather vike a radical redesign.
They are a claimed 34g lighter, now coming in at g a pair, and the battery life has been extended from 60 to 80 hours, trsiner the same AAA battery. Aside from the change from black to silver, there are no other significant changes.
It's a good bet that they'll be functionally almost identical to the P1 pedals, which were very easy to set up and use. When Specialized launched the latest version of the Tarmac Disc, they also entered the power meter market with a range of four cimputer meters, two double-sided models based on Specialized's own S-Works cranks and on the Shimano Dura-Ace cranks, a single-sided S-Works crank and a single-sided Gps cycling walking Ultegra crank.
Specialized has also developed an app for setup and garmln. The lightest setup, without chainrings, is the S-Works carbon dual-sided power crankset, which weighs a claimed ineoor for a Look's latest power meter pedals are a collaboration with original power meter company SRM, which should be a winning combination of Look's vast pedal expertise and SRM's ability to create reliable power-measuring electronics.
The external pods of previous Look power pedals are gone; everything is contained in the pedal's carbon fibre body including rechargeable batteries that Look says give hours of riding time. IQ Square power meter sits indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer your cranks and pedals so there's no need to replace anything. Potential problems include the 32mm increase in the space between your pedals and xomputer patchy history of amazon power meter power meter projects, many of which have started with claims of wonderful products and then collapsed in ignominy and unhappy customers.
It was due to ship in Novemberlater put back to Februaryand while the company claims to have units off the production line none seem to have actually shipped as of this update. It comes without chainrings, but it's compatible with Shimano four-bolt, mm Bikf rings, so Team Zwatt is clearly assuming we all have a pair of those already, a reasonable assumption.
The Zpider has a built-in rechargeable battery with a claimed hour life and magnetic charger. Read our first look at the Team Zwatt Zpider cranks. Read more about the Giant Power Pro cranks. Power2Max makes power-measuring spiders to fit other manufacturers' crank arms, with varying degrees witu functionality depending on how much you ineoor.
The three models for road bikes are: Read more about Power2Max power meters. Joking apart, third time's the charm for these pedals. Garmin has completely redesigned its Vector pedals, and the Vector 3 system is excellent.
You get accurate power readings, they're even easier to swap between bikes, they look much neater and they're even a bit lighter. The Vector 2 inroor weak point was the transmitter pod. It tariner an extra thing to remove and swap, and indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer connection was a bit fiddly, but most of all they were a bit prone to failure: The Vector 3 is an indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer new design, and it does away with the pod completely.
All the electronics are contained within the new pedal body. Everything has been redesigned: There's really nothing left of the Vector 2. New for the Vector 3 is Bluetooth Iwth connectivity. But it's easy to get power and cadence on Bluetooth devices, and indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer tgainer be really useful. Benchmarked against a PowerTap hub and a Kickr smart trainer, the Vector 3s are consistent and accurate, and provide a serious wity of data.
The Vector has really come of age with this bbike. I always get lots of questions about that. Smoothing elevation data is the bane of existence for many of these apps. Some companies like Kinomap have a bunch of solid automation that works well, while others do it can samsung g3 act as bike computer hand.
Yeah, Kinomap does a good job at getting major races loaded in, as does the CylceOps Virtual Training suite. Maybe check out BestBikeSplit, they have basically every Ironman course with hand tunes elevation profiles. Great post, Ray! My hair is now at least as grey as it looks in that first picture. Do you know if any FE-C trainer besides the Kickr supports spin down or zero offset calibration?
It definitely could if someone develops an app for it. Kinomap had talked about it for example, which I felt was a good way to push their wiyh. Tie it to a Kinomap subscription requirement. Any sign of zwift making a connect IQ app so you can control it from say a fenix 3? I ride on rollers I know and it would take exceptional balance for me to use my iPhone to activate boosts or whatever they are without serious injury.
I think it would make sense for some of these apps especially Zwift, but also TR to make a CIQ app for controls like you said. Just powwer much better than a phone with wet hands.
Only available at some large retailers like Decathlon and Halfords it seems, but it might be worth mentioning for those looking at the cheapest entry level trainer that will simulate hills in Zwift. I use the Smart Flow as well as the non-Smart I-genius copmuter to be ungraded. No motor means if you stop pedalling it eventually stops whether up indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer downhill.
I work harder on big downhills but less hard on steeper hills. Btw great reviews, Ray, keep up the good work. I recommend you to all my cycling pals, both in my club and elsewhere. This might not be the right place, but I have a query on resetting the resistance levels when using Zwift with my Tacx Flow.
How can that be? Half baked, really? As someone who is picking schwinn bike computer wheel size numbers their first road bike Specialized Roubaix after being inspired to get into biking while watching the TDF day after day during treadmill drills due to the excessive Midwest dome of heat we experienced, I will undoubtably have use for an indoor trainer.
When I use Set Target Power it usually works quite well. For instance, going from W preset resistance to W, the wheel just keeps spinning like crazy from whatever speed I finished the interval with. Is this something you recognize? For the sake of completeness and accuracy: Pretty cool actually. Again, this is just as proof of concept and I do not recommend this product.
In fact, I stopped using mine and moved along to something else. Indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer and detailed summary. Made my Bushido from obsolete again a Zwift compatible trainer.
Any pictures of the Edge units with the FE-C menus? Just trying to figure out if the user interface is worth the update over using my phone to control the trainer.
Seems like indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer different setup on the which Garmin has a video for. I think we all benefit from this blog! Having recently had issues with my KICKR dropping power he wahoo help desk suggested riding without a Garmin head unit turned on. If this just bad advice or based on something factual in the code or transmission of controlling the trainer via an iPhone?
Would prefer to use edge FE-C bike gps theft tracker just have iPhone capturing data as a secondary point as I always like indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer just in case one file is corrupt. On your product comparison page, you should add a choice after selecting trainers for FE-C compatible.
Kind of a pain to do this when you change resistance, etc. Like it gets the message to change resistance then it gives up and goes back to normal.
Thanks for yet another good article. I have a question about setting target power with the Edge and the Tacx Neo. Everytime I set a given wattage, the wheel just keeps spinning with no resistance at all. I tested with an Edgeand that worked flawlessly.
Using resistance levels works fine. Referring to this line, it seems like this works for you: Can you please clarify which Edge device you are using to control indoor bike trainer stand computer target power? Have you tried with Edge ?
I think this is one of those bugs which I am eagerly awaiting to be fixed. Well last night on the trainer tacx vortex in frustration I metter this several times and it goddamn finally worked!
There is some bug here because the resistance works no problem but the communication seems broken with the power. Once again Garmin should update the indoor trainer profile to give you the option to change power and not dig through the main screen.
All resistance drops off when switching to target power. The resistance mode works. Same issue with both and Tried the out of the box and same issue. Thanks for your reply. For a tenth of a second I can feel Tacx Neo responding — It increases the watt for a very short period less than a secondand then cuts off all resistance and the wheel indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer keeps spinning.
Very weird. I did another workout today with the Set Target Power option on the Edgeand no drop-outs either. I also did another with the Edge and best low priced gps option.
This is weird! My old man has just indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer a Tacx Neo, so I was reading all neo and turbo related posts, and started to wonder about the FEC garmmin. So first question: Not with the views on cyce obviously, but to simulate the elevation.
I just ordered a Tacx Vortex Smart farmin few days ago, and was excitedly awaiting its arrival! I have a question about Bluetooth trainer control. Indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer the native chcle app can control computer with best battery life trainer via Bluetooth not keen on paying the big bucks for that app thoughbut what other 3rd party apps are compatible.
Last question…Do you foresee Zwift introducing a mobile either phone or tablet app for the regular experience or is the program just far too complex to not play on a computer without a dedicated graphics card? I have tried for the past 2 winters have TR control bikf vortex. I have never had this work very well. Have numerous emails to both Tacx and TR, both have tried to help, neither very well.
Oh, if you are a chocolate fan, then chocolate therapy is the flavor compute get. I have this exact setup, Win 8. Works flawlessly with TR and Zwift. When I set mine up early this year, I did look at some troubleshooting indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer.
Mine is 1 m away, wjth fine, but IIRC, some household electromag interference can require pretty close proximity between the transmitter copmuter receiver. In the upcoming trainer app guide, it would be good to hear how Golden Cheetah 3. FE-C and riding Sufferfest or such clips. What do you expect from Eurobike in terms of Smart trainers? I have an old 5 level of resistance no-smart mag trainer i want to replace with a smart trainer. So basically my question is what upgrades do you expect there to be in new smart trainers?
Lower noise levels? Higher resistance? Better road feel which is think is pretty gimmicky personally. Finally great article again and keep up the great work you sigma bike computer bc 8.12. I really indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer take your traiber in high regard when considering new equipment.
I expect simply more models at the mid-range price level, thus increasing competition and lowering prices at the upper end of that tier. So — I got my eyes on the Neo and I am juuust garmib to pull the trigger! However, there are numerous companies releasing units with potentially similar features garmin bicycle maps potentially lower price points.
And the direct-drive. I tried it and loved it!
Ray — Thank you for the insight. I am totally undecided between traijer Neo which I have in my shopping cart on lots of sites already!! Tacx has opened up the Bluetooth Specs, and some developers do use it i.
However, as I explained in the article the challenge with that is that each company has their own take on it. So each app has to then code for each new trainer brand and sometimes each new model.
I would never go back to using a laptop for trainer rides. The ipad is so much better for the purpose and you can get an ANT plug for it too. I bought an iPad explicitly to use with TR with my new Tacx vortex smart.
Even bought the mic stand setup Ray did a cyclw about indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer few years ago. I live way out in the country. Which is a lot of money for a little bit of data allowance.
It really depends on the apps as to how much indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer. The FE-C piece of things will use zero data on your plan, but the apps themselves may depending on how the app operates.
Apps like Zwift for example update often, and updates can be upwards of 1GB in some cases. I have had problem with my Indopr relatively early unit and after the a very amateurish customer service experience, they finally just said contact the reseller Clever Training who has not returned email — I standing bike with computer another replacement, which was completely defective, but they have ignored emails.
I think Tacx has a very European attitude to customer service.
If you are in N. America, I would not buy a Tacx. For that money, I would expect premium service. They looked at all support channels and found nothing.
But I think that Clever Training in this case has done pretty much everything they can to try and solve your issue. It will be a big step in the right direction even if the rowing activity is recorded as indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer activity on the Edge If you re-ride an activity or garmin edge 820 gps bike computer review using a Garmin Edge will it use the GPS data in addition to elevation data and save that as part of the activity?
I assume not but is there a way to do that? Hi Ray, big fan of your site for some time now. Or does it use a private channel? Thanks a lot and congrts for the site and baby! Thank you Ray. Do you have the protocoll or a link maybe? Thanks and Greets Tim.
Just sign up to be an Adopter on thisisant. Luckily zwift programmers have ensured my model will work with zwift,but unfortunately not with trainer road. I must be missing something imdoor. A question: Indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer polar v650 update possible to capture a workout on a Garmin Edge and have it appear in Garmin Connect?
You can record the workout, which will show up like any recorded trainer activity. Where power, speed and cadence will be taken from trainer while HR from hrm belt? I like the bkool set up and zwift, but the problem is that my trainer cannot be found by their software programs. Thanks Robby. Any thoughts? Which one is better for Zwift?
And what is your recommendation? Thanks in advance! Found this article really, really useful — I have just purchased a TACX Flow smart trainer [xmas indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer to self] and want to know if it will connect to my Garmin Edge ? Can a Computrainer Why is my phone interfering with my bike computer from offer controlled resistance with Zwift?
Im less concerned about the road feel as i am about realistic resistance control ie. Correct unfortunately on the Kinetic. The Wahoo lightning dongle with old style to new style lightning adapter for newer iPhone and iPad models works ondoor for all ANT purposes. Which app allows straight forward and somewhat precise or resistance calibration. When I tried to contact Elite on this either their site is in Italian does not polar v650 update supported English protocol and their is nothing on the web that gives any direction for their product.
In fact, the Elite reporting made me look like a Tour de France winner! I used the Elite e-training app on my iPad to recalibrate and it made a massive improvement. The app needs to sync against a known power meter I used my Quarq and you basically do a 20 minute ride on cokputer flat, moderate, and steep slopes. The calibration process was miserable, and I needed to do it twice in fact, because indoor bike trainer with power meter garmin cycle computer app is less-than-perfect.
In the end, the app gives three numbers P1, P2, P3 which are uploaded into the trainer and reset way it reports power. Anyway, in my situation it made a big difference and now the Elite rollers match my Quarq within a percentage or two, depending on how I smooth the data.
In this regard, folks like Powertap, Quarq, Wahoo, all blow them out of the water. Computef really, because they make nice equipment. I had the same problem and contacted Elite support here:
News:All workouts require a bike, a trainer, and a computer (laptop or (Dual Band) Speed Sensor (Wahoo Fitness Speed and Cadence Sensor) Be sure to select the The Android beta supports most ANT+, ANT+ FE-C and Bluetooth Smart power meters, smart trainers, Using Head Units (e.g. Garmin ) with TrainerRoad.
Leave a Comment